The Other Side of Electric Cars

Electric vehicles can help reduce harmful greenhouse emissions, but a new study suggests that, without cleaner sources of electricity, the environmental benefits would be limited.

Wow! You may be wondering how this could be true. The Wall Street Journal released an article on October 10th called “Electric Cars: Less Environmentally Friendly than They Seem”. As soon as I saw that article I knew that it was something that would spark my interest. The author, Daniel Akst, also wrote about how the environmental cost of manufacturing electric cars is worse than manufacturing gas-powered cars:

In addition to dirty sources of power, the environmental advantages of electric vehicles are dampened by the global warming impact of manufacturing them, which is about twice the comparable impact of conventional vehicles.

The article also includes how even if the electricity was generated from a fairly clean source of gas there would only be limited benefits for the environment. Electric cars also can only go 100-200 miles before they need to be recharged. This limitation means that you would have to stop more often to “fill up” only to drive a shorter distance than a gasoline-powered car could go . Electric cars also are lagging behind gasoline-powered cars in convenience. They have heavy chargers, they take 4-8 hours to get fully charged, and 30 minutes for about 80% of a charge. This means that they are less convenient and also less environmentally friendly than they seem.

So which is better? They both have their pros and cons for the environment so it is very hard to tell how the pros and cons would even out. The pro for gasoline-powered cars is they don’t pollute as much to manufacture, but the con is polluting whenever it is producing exhaust. The pro for electric vehicles is that they don’t pollute while driving, but the cons are the environmental cost to make them and also having to charge with power form fossil fuels.


2 responses to “The Other Side of Electric Cars”

  1. Colby says :

    Adam, I really liked your post because I have a strong affinity for cars. This was also interesting because people assume that just because electric cars are an alternative source of fuel, they are good for the environment. I liked this article because it challenged that idea in an informative way. I still think electric cars are better because they don’t use fossil fuels, but this article made me change my way of thinking. Good job.

    • adamw0017 says :

      Thank you Colby. I was looking on my RSS feed and i thought that it would be a fun topic to look into. I also agree that electric cars are better than gasoline-powered cars, but I now have more information on both types of cars.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: